We Tried 10 Brands to Find the Best Popcorn | Taste of Home

Every column merchandise is independently selected, though we may be compensated or receive an consort commission if you buy something through our links. Ratings and prices are accurate and items are in stock as of fourth dimension of issue.

You’ve got your movie queued up, you’re in your comfy clothes—all that’s left is picking the perfect snack. Lucky for you, we’ve done the hard work and found the best popcorn.

When it comes to settling in with a commodity movie, one thing ’ randomness for certain : you need the right snacks. While I typically like to mix gratifying and salty ( like in these fresh and piquant nosh recipes ), I can ’ t deny how satisfying a impertinently popped base of popcorn can be .
Of course, if I ’ megabyte going to be binge-watching television receiver, I ’ megabyte going to want that popcorn to be reasonably mend tasty. so to find the best popcorn this side of the field, I rounded up a crew of taste testers to put these 10 brands to the screen :

  • 365 Everyday Value
  • Act II
  • Black Jewell
  • Jolly Time
  • Koepsell’s Popping Corn
  • Newman’s Own
  • Orville Redenbacher’s
  • Pop Secret
  • Quinn
  • Skinny Pop

Find out how which brand you should reach for the adjacent time you ’ re at the grocery memory. ( You can besides make homemade microwave popcorn in a paper bag. )

Best Movie Theater Style: Pop Secret


“ Look at these big downy kernels ! ”
Score: 6.5/10
Recreating movie-theater dash popcorn at home is constantly a difficult undertaking. It seems like no matter what you do, it ’ south never quite as tasty and addict as those concession stand buckets. But once in a while, a microwave popcorn can come pretty close to that movie magic—enter Pop Secret .
This microwave popcorn offered us adult, downy kernels with a satisfying crush. When it came to the butter taste, we all agreed this one tasted a set like movie dramaturgy popcorn ( a gold standard for some ). It had a stronger butter season than most brands, but it was in no way overwhelming or excessively artificial. surely, our fingers were a moment greasy in the end, but it was a minor price to pay for this movie theater-style bite .
available nationally and via Amazon .
Hey, have you ever wondered why you have to microwave popcorn “ this side up ” ? here ’ s the answer .

Best Natural Brand: Black Jewell


“ This just tastes so fresh and good. ”
Score: 7.2/10
Up future was natural brand Black Jewell. From the beginning, Black Jewell stood aside from our early best popcorn competitors due to its appearance. The hull of each cloud-like pop was distinctly darkened because of the trade name ’ s decision to use black corn, a diverseness common to South America. ( Some testers asked if this popcorn overstayed its welcome in the microwave, but I can assure you that ’ s fair the black hulls. )
Did you know there ’ south white-kernel corn, besides ? here ’ s the breakdown .
Black Jewell besides stood out to us for its great taste. The smaller kernels used in this popcorn offered us an extra crunchy snacking experience. The butter flavoring on this microwave popcorn was elusive but decidedly realistic—great for popcorn purists .
besides worth noting : This popcorn is non-GMO and offers more antioxidants than its other popcorn counterparts, so you can feel pretty good about this nosh as you click “ keep determine. ”
available at blue-ribbon retailers nationally and Black Jewell ’ s web site .

Best Mom-and-“Pop”: Koepsell’s Popping Corn


“ This is like antique, air-popped popcorn—so estimable. ”
Score: 7.3/10
Coming in merely ahead of Black Jewell was the Wisconsin-based Koepsell ’ s Popping Corn. Like Black Jewell, Koepsell ’ s popcorn kernels are much smaller than what you normally see at the field or at the grocery store store. But what this popcorn lacks in size, it makes up for in taste !
These small kernels were absolutely crunchy and even a little balmy sample. But what actually set this sword apart from the pack was the perplex butter spirit coating each man. As a gang of butter-lovers, this was crucial standard for this test, and Koepsell ’ sulfur blew us away with its arrant butter spirit. Looking at the scorecards, one tester put it concisely : “ tastes AWESOME. ” Psst ! Learn which brand of butter we can ’ thyroxine get enough of .
available at Wisconsin grocers and Koepsell ’ s web site .

Best in Show: 365 Everyday Value


“ This one has such a beneficial botch to it ! ”
Score: 9.1/10
Ending up with one of our highest quiz scores always was whole Foods ’ 365 casual Value. Testers ranked this choice as the best popcorn because it combined our front-runner aspects of our early top picks : texture, appearance and smooth pantry flavor .
This popcorn stood out to us because, like Pop Secret, it offered colossus downy kernels of popcorn. It sincerely looked video perfect to us. It besides was exceptionally crunchy without having besides many stick-in-your-teeth hulls bothering us. Light and airy, our picking for best popcorn besides had a fall, authentic butter taste—enough to satisfy folks craving more than basic popcorn but not therefore much that you found yourself left with greasy fingers. Do you know how to make popcorn on the stove ?

available at Whole Foods countrywide and via Amazon .

The Takeaways

Stray from the norm

When it came to the results, we were all shocked that less recognizable brands claimed three out of the four top spots. It turns out that taking a gamble at the grocery store memory on unique and recess brands can provide some of the tastiest results .

It’s all about the butter

As we began this test, participants chatted about whether or not fudge butter was a pro or a victimize when it came to microwave butter. many folks ( myself included ) admitted to just enjoying that fake butter taste that you get at the movie theater, but in the end, this screen revealed that there ’ south nothing like authentic butter season. Our top three picks all got eminent marks for tasting like the real thing .
desire to take popcorn to the following level ? Try these season popcorn recipes for a flavor-packed bite .

Get popping with these popcorn-packed recipes

1 / 21

1 / 21

Chewy Caramel Coated Popcorn Exps Thca17 197107 D11 03 2b 12

Chewy Caramel-Coated Popcorn

When I was a kyd, my ma made this recipe often. I ‘ve adapted it to make it more chewy and gooey than her crunchy, nut-loaded translation. I get requests to make this for every event that I host, and have never had a single leftover ! —Shannon Dobos, Calgary, Alberta Go to Recipe

When I was a kid, my mom made this recipe often. I’ve adapted it to make it more chewy and gooey than her crunchy, nut-loaded version. I get requests to make this for every event that I host, and have never had a single leftover! —Shannon Dobos, Calgary, AlbertaMake sure you know how to make popcorn on the stove

Easy White Chocolate Party Mix preference of Home

Easy White Chocolate Party Mix

I get rave reviews every time I prepare this crisp combination of cereal, popcorn, pretzels, nuts and candies. Coated in whiten cocoa, this mix is spectacular for parties and for give giving. —Rose Wentzel, St. Louis, Missouri Go to Recipe

I get rave reviews every time I prepare this crispy combination of cereal, popcorn, pretzels, nuts and candies. Coated in white chocolate, this mix is spectacular for parties and for gift giving. —Rose Wentzel, St. Louis, Missouri

Exps9587 Mrr14329709 09 1b 5

Courtside Caramel Corn

My guests say they ca n’t stop eating my caramel corn ! For our basketball party I fix adequate to fill a big red tin with our team ‘s logo. The delectable syrup coats the popcorn well but is n’t sticky. —Sharon Landeen, Tucson, Arizona Go to Recipe

My guests say they can’t stop eating my caramel corn! For our basketball party I fix enough to fill a big red tin with our team’s logo. The delectable syrup coats the popcorn well but isn’t sticky. —Sharon Landeen, Tucson, Arizona

Parmesan Ranch Popcorn Exps Bpm22 163727 Dr 04 15 2b

Parmesan Ranch Popcorn

Whether you need a quick give idea or delectable munchies for movie night, we ‘ve got you covered with this bum braid on regular popped popcorn. —Taste of Home Test Kitchen Go to Recipe

Whether you need a quick gift idea or yummy munchies for movie night, we’ve got you covered with this cheesy twist on regular popped popcorn. —Taste of Home Test Kitchen

Striped Chocolate Popcorn Exps Cmz18 26151 C10 27 3b 6

Striped Chocolate Popcorn

For a bake sale death year, I wanted to try something different. I ’ d seen cocoa popcorn in a candy workshop and thought I ’ five hundred try on making it. This recipe was a great achiever. —Mary Schmittinger, Colgate, Wisconsin Go to Recipe

For a bake sale last year, I wanted to try something different. I’d seen chocolate popcorn in a candy shop and thought I’d try making it. This recipe was a great success. —Mary Schmittinger, Colgate, Wisconsin

Gingerbread Caramel Crunch Exps Tohca20 49942 B03 13 3b 4

Gingerbread Caramel Crunch

If you love gingerbread, you wo n’t be able to resist this crisp, crunchy popcorn. munch it yourself or share it as a tasty gift ! —Lynne Weigle-Snow, Alexandria, Virginia Go to Recipe

If you love gingerbread, you won’t be able to resist this crispy, crunchy popcorn. Munch it yourself or share it as a tasty gift! —Lynne Weigle-Snow, Alexandria, Virginia

Nacho Popcorn taste of Home

Nacho Popcorn

My husband and I like to munch on this while watching television receiver. The nacho season is a piquant alternative to butter and salt. —Linda Boehme, Fairmont, Minnesota Go to Recipe

My husband and I like to munch on this while watching TV. The nacho flavoring is a zesty alternative to butter and salt. —Linda Boehme, Fairmont, Minnesota

Exps35914 13x9163826b10 16 2b 3

Ranch Popcorn

What ’ second movie night at home without some popcorn to munch ? Try a big bathtub of this buttery, showstopping blend. It ’ south easy, bum and finger-lickin ’ adept. —Taste of Home Test Kitchen Go to Recipe

What’s movie night at home without some popcorn to munch? Try a big tub of this buttery, showstopping blend. It’s easy, cheesy and finger-lickin’ good. —Taste of Home Test Kitchen

Marshmallow-Peanut Popcorn taste of Home

Marshmallow-Peanut Popcorn

My brother calls this jazz band of popcorn, marshmallows, peanuts and pretzels the “ perfect popcorn. ” The taste is evocative of a Big Hunk candy bar. —Julie Perez, Idaho Falls, Idaho Go to Recipe

My brother calls this combo of popcorn, marshmallows, peanuts and pretzels the “perfect popcorn.” The taste is reminiscent of a Big Hunk candy bar. —Julie Perez, Idaho Falls, Idaho

Peanut Butter Lover S Popcorn Exps163726 Sd2401789c08 13 1b Rms

Peanut Butter Lover’s Popcorn

A fun way to jazz up popcorn. —Taste of Home Test Kitchen Go to Recipe

A fun way to jazz up popcorn. —Taste of Home Test Kitchen

Peppermint Popcorn Taste of Home

Peppermint Popcorn

Crisp and minty, this dim-witted popcorn nosh is a hit with all 10 of our children. For variety show, use whatever kind of sugarcoat you like. —Shirley Mars, Kent, Ohio Go to Recipe

Crisp and minty, this simple popcorn snack is a hit with all 10 of our children. For variety, use whatever kind of candy you like. —Shirley Mars, Kent, Ohio

Chocolate Mint Popcorn Exps127605 Th143190c10 09 11bc Rms 4

Chocolate-Mint Popcorn

I wrote a koran called “ 20 New Ways to Enjoy Popcorn. ” When I poll friends, they favor this recipe, a delightful treat for after-dinner chocolate. — Polly Brunning, Thaxton, Virginia Go to Recipe

I wrote a book called “20 New Ways to Enjoy Popcorn.” When I poll friends, they favor this recipe, a delicious treat for after-dinner coffee. — Polly Brunning, Thaxton, Virginia

Buffalo Ranch Popcorn Exps Tohas22 50198 Gns 03 24 7b

Buffalo Ranch Popcorn

This bouncing american bison chicken season blend is certain to spice up your favorite bite. It ‘s perfect for game time, movie clock time, or as a special after-school bite. Be sure to drizzle the sauce mixture over the popcorn gradually, differently you ‘ll end up with inert popcorn. —Jenny McCarthy, Sussex, Wisconsin Go to Recipe

This zippy buffalo chicken flavored blend is sure to spice up your favorite snack. It’s perfect for game time, movie time, or as a special after-school snack. Be sure to drizzle the sauce mixture over the popcorn gradually, otherwise you’ll end up with soggy popcorn. —Jenny McCarthy, Sussex, Wisconsin

Halloween Snack Mix taste of Home

Halloween Snack Mix

hera is a simple bite mix I created on the spur of the moment. It ‘s easy to toss together for a Halloween party or to package in person bags for a decrease bake sale. —Barbara Roberts, Middleton, Wisconsin Go to Recipe

Here is a simple snack mix I created on the spur of the moment. It’s easy to toss together for a Halloween party or to package in individual bags for a fall bake sale. —Barbara Roberts, Middleton, Wisconsin

Rosemary Parmesan Popcorn Exps50087 Wth1999449b06 07 5bc Rms 3

Rosemary-Parmesan Popcorn

Fresh herb and real cheese make this popcorn a homemade front-runner that will make you forget about boughten seasoning mixes. —Dan Kelmenson, West Bloomfield, Michigan Go to Recipe

Fresh herbs and real cheese make this popcorn a homemade favorite that will make you forget about store-bought seasoning mixes. —Dan Kelmenson, West Bloomfield, Michigan

Peanut Caramel Corn Exps110825 Thhc2238741b07 25 3b Rms 4

Peanut Caramel Corn

A sweet, crunchy, easy alternative to traditional caramel corn, this can’t-stop-eatin’-it treat wo n’t stick to fingers or tooth ! Wonderful for gifts, excessively. —Lois Ward, Puslinch, Ontario Go to Recipe

A sweet, crunchy, lighter alternative to traditional caramel corn, this can’t-stop-eatin’-it treat won’t stick to fingers or teeth! Wonderful for gifts, too. —Lois Ward, Puslinch, Ontario

Sweet Tooth Popcorn Exps49941 Rds2321892c04 26 2bc Rms 2

Sweet-Tooth Popcorn

I like to be creative with this popcorn recipe and add different things to make it gay for the holidays. Everyone says the sweet and salty sample is addicting. —Daynna Puckett, Broken Bow, Oklahoma Go to Recipe

I like to be creative with this popcorn recipe and add different things to make it festive for the holidays. Everyone says the sweet and salty taste is addicting. —Daynna Puckett, Broken Bow, Oklahoma

Movie Night Munchie Mix Exps123732 Cwc2492080c02 01 1b Rms 4

Movie Night Munchie Mix

Why not enjoy concession-style snacks at dwelling ? I took some of my favorites and combined them to make a sweetness and savory mix. —Dawn Moore, Warren, Pennsylvania Go to Recipe

Why not enjoy concession-style snacks at home? I took some of my favorites and combined them to make a sweet and savory mix. —Dawn Moore, Warren, Pennsylvania

Sesame-Ginger Popcorn taste of Home

Sesame-Ginger Popcorn

Enjoy this asian twist to popcorn on movie night. —Taste of Home Test Kitchen Go to Recipe

Enjoy this Asian twist to popcorn on movie night. —Taste of Home Test Kitchen

Maple Crunch Popcorn Exps49262 Cx2376979a09 14 6b Rmspg 2

Maple Crunch Popcorn

For a bite that ‘s certain to bring smiles, try this medley of popcorn and pecans covered in a fresh and buttery coating.—Elmira Trombetti, Paducah, Kentucky Go to Recipe

For a snack that’s sure to bring smiles, try this medley of popcorn and pecans covered in a sweet and buttery coating.—Elmira Trombetti, Paducah, Kentucky

Candy Corn & Peanut Popcorn Balls taste of Home

Candy Corn & Peanut Popcorn Balls

My daughter and I enjoy baking and cooking together, and this recipe is one my daughter can help make and then share at school.—Kim Shireman, Searcy, Arkansas Go to Recipe

My daughter and I enjoy baking and cooking together, and this recipe is one my daughter can help make and then share at school.—Kim Shireman, Searcy, Arkansas

Popular Videos